The Supreme Court has declined to certify a proposed class action lawsuit against the Government of Canada for its role in allowing Indigenous children to be taken into state care and placed in non-Indigenous homes.
The class action focuses on 1992 to 2019 – also known as the Millennial Scoop or Millennium Scoop – and alleges placement in non-Indigenous homes resulted in a loss of identity, culture, family and federal benefits for affected Indigenous children.
On June 20, 2022, the Federal Court of Canada certified the class action lawsuit. That was later overturned by the Federal Court of Appeal on the basis that many of the documents and information relevant to the claim lie not with Canada, but with the provinces, territories and child welfare agencies that actually made the placement decisions.
Canada does not have possession, power or control over documents and information relevant to the claim, according to the Federal Court of Appeal’s decision.
Though provinces and territories deliver child welfare services, Angela Bespflug – one of the lawyers representing lead plaintiff Cheyenne Pamamukos Stonechild in the lawsuit – recently told ICT News Canada has a constitutional duty to protect the cultural identity of Indigenous children.
Certification is a required step for a lawsuit to proceed on behalf of a group of people rather than as an individual claim.
More follows.



